I saw a commentary/wrap up on Good Morning America this morning about the decision to allow the building of a mosque at the Ground Zero site in New York City. It was interesting to watch ABC's George Stephanopoulos talking about this issue with a Fox News contributer (announced as such) who focused in the story on the fairness of the brand new mosque being approved when a Greek Orthodox congregation that was destroyed in 2001 has not been allowed to rebuild.
The story has gotten a lot attraction in the blogosphere, both from neutral and less neutral sources, but I thought it was interesting to compare both networks' coverage.
ABC here.
Fox here.
Showing posts with label Islam. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Islam. Show all posts
Wednesday, August 4, 2010
Thursday, April 1, 2010
Great summary of Europe issues with Muslim headscarves from EJC
The European Journalism Centre, which provides resources to journalists working in the European Union, has this resource-rich blog post about the issues with Muslim women and headscarves that have appeared in Europe and most notably France.
Tuesday, March 16, 2010
Are religion and nationality interchangeable?
Check out this lead story from The New York Times' web site.
The blurb reads "Clashes broke out between Palestinian youths and Israeli forces on Tuesday as an activist group drew attention to plans for more Jewish housing units."
For discussion: In a story like this, when is it appropriate to use national identity and when is it appropriate to use religious identity?
The blurb reads "Clashes broke out between Palestinian youths and Israeli forces on Tuesday as an activist group drew attention to plans for more Jewish housing units."
For discussion: In a story like this, when is it appropriate to use national identity and when is it appropriate to use religious identity?
Saturday, February 27, 2010
Article looks at history of inter-Islamic conflict
An Op-Ed piece in the The New York Times follows on the Olympics with the story of the dissolution of the Islamic Solidarity Games this year because host country Iran wrote the words "Persian Gulf" on the flag for the event.
A quote from the story: "In this history of a single body of water, one sees a perfect example of the so-called Islamic Paradox that dates from the seventh century. For although the Prophet Muhammad took great pains to underscore the equality of all believers regardless of ethnicity, categorically forbidding any fighting among the believers, his precepts have been constantly and blatantly violated.
It took a mere 24 years after the Prophet’s death for the head of the universal Islamic community, the caliph Uthman, to be murdered by political rivals. This opened the floodgates to incessant infighting within the House of Islam, which has never ceased. "
A quote from the story: "In this history of a single body of water, one sees a perfect example of the so-called Islamic Paradox that dates from the seventh century. For although the Prophet Muhammad took great pains to underscore the equality of all believers regardless of ethnicity, categorically forbidding any fighting among the believers, his precepts have been constantly and blatantly violated.
It took a mere 24 years after the Prophet’s death for the head of the universal Islamic community, the caliph Uthman, to be murdered by political rivals. This opened the floodgates to incessant infighting within the House of Islam, which has never ceased. "
Thursday, January 21, 2010
Jesus Rifles gain attention
Stephen Colbert calls them "an armor-piercing Sunday School," while other media outlets have more serious stories.
Fox News
ABC news
American Public Radio
For discussion: How do the different media approach the story?
Fox News
ABC news
American Public Radio
For discussion: How do the different media approach the story?
Wednesday, September 16, 2009
Discrimination study gives ideas for class discussion
A new Pew study you can shows that Americans believe Muslims and homosexuals are the most discriminated against groups in the U.S., media are reporting today.
A look at the original study could lead to interesting class discussions on how the media covered this study and in particular the religious issues it brings up and how religious groups treat homosexuals and how you cover that.
Saturday, September 12, 2009
Article tries to integrate diet advice, dietary laws
This article, run during Ramadan and shortly before Yom Kippur looks at a wide variety of religious eating practices and their likely effects on health.
Although the health advice is short and shallow, the thumbnail sketch of Kosher meat preparation was interesting. Islam, Buddhism and Hinduism are all mentioned, but much more scantily.
Thursday, September 3, 2009
"Apostate killing" threatened in U.S.
CNN has this piece about a teenager who says her father threatened to kill her for converting to Christianity.
The article, which quotes the teen, her attorney and her family's attorney, quotes her father indirectly as saying the local mosque encouraged him to "deal with the problem," which readers would interpret as eliminate the youth.
There was little context in the story about the fate of Muslims who convert to Christianity, which has certainly been an issue in the past year in other countries. Even some links to those stories would have help provide some much-needed background beyond the he-said, she-said of this article.
Monday, August 17, 2009
I'm gonna need to ask you to uncover that, Ma'am
This article from the LA Times about a woman's eviction from a public pool for wearing a full-body swimsuit as a Muslim woman is interesting because of the quotations used.
French authorities are quoted as saying:
"Islamic bathing suits don't exist in the Koran"
"In our country we cannot accept women prisoners behind a wire fence, cut off from all social life, deprived of all identity."
"This is the tip of the fundamentalist iceberg."
While Islamic sources, including the woman who was evicted are quoted:
"When Sarkozy says the burka is a problem for the 'dignity of women,' it means he's already finished his investigation."
Her only battle is "simply to be able to swim with my children in a pool."
What seemed to be missing from both sides was an idea that a woman might actually want to wear such a suit, on her own, without coercion from religious authorities.
French authorities are quoted as saying:
"Islamic bathing suits don't exist in the Koran"
"In our country we cannot accept women prisoners behind a wire fence, cut off from all social life, deprived of all identity."
"This is the tip of the fundamentalist iceberg."
While Islamic sources, including the woman who was evicted are quoted:
"When Sarkozy says the burka is a problem for the 'dignity of women,' it means he's already finished his investigation."
Her only battle is "simply to be able to swim with my children in a pool."
What seemed to be missing from both sides was an idea that a woman might actually want to wear such a suit, on her own, without coercion from religious authorities.
Labels:
Freedom of Speech,
Government,
Islam,
Women
Thursday, August 6, 2009
AEJMC annual meeting returns
Religion and Media interest Group members have gathered in Boston to hear the latest research, and to discuss issues in media and religion. One panel, scheduled for tomorrow at 12:15, will look at why certain groups in society hate journalists and what journalists can do to treat these groups fairly and win their trust.
One group that may feel it gets unfair treatment in the US media is Muslims, so I thought this CNN package from Christiane Amanpour was an interesting one.
One group that may feel it gets unfair treatment in the US media is Muslims, so I thought this CNN package from Christiane Amanpour was an interesting one.
Saturday, February 28, 2009
Sharia adopted as peacemaking measure in Somalia
Another country has agreed with rebel groups to institute Sharia, or Islamic law, in order to gain a cease-fire.
Somali President Sharif Sheikh Ahmed announced today that he has approved the installation of Sharia Law, a move that will have to be ratified by the nation's parliament.
Stories about the move were pretty similar from the BBC and from Al Jazeera, although the latter focused more on the political aspect, while the BBC focused more on the violence.
Somalia has been cited by Christian rights groups for incidents where professions Christians and Christian converts have been beheaded.
Somali President Sharif Sheikh Ahmed announced today that he has approved the installation of Sharia Law, a move that will have to be ratified by the nation's parliament.
Stories about the move were pretty similar from the BBC and from Al Jazeera, although the latter focused more on the political aspect, while the BBC focused more on the violence.
Somalia has been cited by Christian rights groups for incidents where professions Christians and Christian converts have been beheaded.
Sunday, February 22, 2009
Viewer reports detail experience of wearing religious clothing
This series of iReports from CNN has first-person accounts from members of various religions explaining the meaning of clothing they wear and the reactions that they get. Perspectives include Muslim, Sikh and Orthodox Jew.
The unedited candor of the presentations is compelling.
The unedited candor of the presentations is compelling.
Monday, February 16, 2009
News outlets cover Pakistan sharia law deal
As was widely reported yesterday, in an effort to boost security in the mountainous Swat region, the Pakistani government has reached a deal with the Taliban to return the region to Islamic law.
In covering a story like this for a Western audience, context is critical if you want the readers/viewers to understand why this is significant. The Associated Press Coverage found here focuses on the U.S. political reaction, with only glancing attention to the issues that shariah law might bring about for civilians living in the region.
Another article published in the National, from Abu Dhabi, offers a lengthy historical context detailing the relationship of shariah law and the relative peace within the region.
CNN's international edition had a few grafs on the social impact here.
Reuters, a few years ago, ran a summary of sharia law in the context of another story. The brief summary does highlight some of the cultural issues that might be important for a Western audience.
In covering a story like this for a Western audience, context is critical if you want the readers/viewers to understand why this is significant. The Associated Press Coverage found here focuses on the U.S. political reaction, with only glancing attention to the issues that shariah law might bring about for civilians living in the region.
Another article published in the National, from Abu Dhabi, offers a lengthy historical context detailing the relationship of shariah law and the relative peace within the region.
CNN's international edition had a few grafs on the social impact here.
Reuters, a few years ago, ran a summary of sharia law in the context of another story. The brief summary does highlight some of the cultural issues that might be important for a Western audience.
Saturday, November 29, 2008
Article explores role of Islam in India
Beginning with a quote from a gunman at the Oberoi Hotel, this article in Time looks at the status of Muslims in India. The gunman is quoted as saying that the attacks were revenge for the poor treatment of Muslims in that country.
In India, Muslims are less than 20 percent of the population, but, according to the article, "...generally speaking, Muslim Indians have shorter life spans, worse health, lower literacy levels and lower-paying jobs."
The article takes a historical approach and is a good background for understanding tensions within India and with the country's neighboring Islamic Republic of Pakistan.
Also of interest is this older article from Religion and Ethics Newsweekly.
In India, Muslims are less than 20 percent of the population, but, according to the article, "...generally speaking, Muslim Indians have shorter life spans, worse health, lower literacy levels and lower-paying jobs."
The article takes a historical approach and is a good background for understanding tensions within India and with the country's neighboring Islamic Republic of Pakistan.
Also of interest is this older article from Religion and Ethics Newsweekly.
Labels:
Hinduism,
History,
In the news,
Islam,
teachable moment
Thursday, November 13, 2008
What is in a word?
In Somalia, there is a steady encroachment on key towns and ports, thanks to a militia belonging to a group called Shabab.
But what do you call the militia members as a group. If you are the LA Times, you call them islamic insurgents, but on the other coast, the NY Times calls them islamist insurgents.
According to religionstylebook.org, there is a difference, and an islamist is using a fundamentalist interpretation of Islam to further a political agenda, whereas Islamic is a more general-purpose adjective.
But what do you call the militia members as a group. If you are the LA Times, you call them islamic insurgents, but on the other coast, the NY Times calls them islamist insurgents.
According to religionstylebook.org, there is a difference, and an islamist is using a fundamentalist interpretation of Islam to further a political agenda, whereas Islamic is a more general-purpose adjective.
Saturday, November 8, 2008
Blog aggregates stories of Muslim women in media
This blog, written by a group of Muslim feminists, provides analysis, commentary and aggregations of stories in the media that feature Muslim women.
The blog covers a world-wide area and a variety of news media and is worth a look.
The blog covers a world-wide area and a variety of news media and is worth a look.
Thursday, October 2, 2008
Blog post questions media coverage choices
This post at the blog Bitch, Ph.D. has a musing on Eid-al-Fitr, including a reference to a news story about a mosque in Dayton, OH, where some sprayed an irritating gas into the mosque nursery during prayers.
The end of the post, which analyzes the play of the story is more interesting:
"A Google News Search-culled sample of some of the news outlets that have covered the story: BeliefNet, Huffington Post, Israeli News, Wisconsin Progressive.org, MidEastYouth.org, DemocracyNow, and a handful of local Ohio outlets. Notice anything? Not a single major outlet. Not the New York Times, the Washington Post, CNN, or even the Trib.
It's disgusting. I'd wager a week's pay with you that if someone sprayed an irritant gas into a church or a synagogue or a g-d (edited) Girl Scouts meeting, where children were hurt, it would be a "story" for at least one day. But here, the story is inconvenient. Hell, all those Muslims just go around killing each other anyway, right? Isn't that what they're doing in Iraq?"
The end of the post, which analyzes the play of the story is more interesting:
"A Google News Search-culled sample of some of the news outlets that have covered the story: BeliefNet, Huffington Post, Israeli News, Wisconsin Progressive.org, MidEastYouth.org, DemocracyNow, and a handful of local Ohio outlets. Notice anything? Not a single major outlet. Not the New York Times, the Washington Post, CNN, or even the Trib.
It's disgusting. I'd wager a week's pay with you that if someone sprayed an irritant gas into a church or a synagogue or a g-d (edited) Girl Scouts meeting, where children were hurt, it would be a "story" for at least one day. But here, the story is inconvenient. Hell, all those Muslims just go around killing each other anyway, right? Isn't that what they're doing in Iraq?"
Sunday, September 21, 2008
Blair course covered in PR website, Daily Show
The Daily Show host Jon Stewart's lengthy Friday interview with former British Prime Minister Tony Blair is worth a look for the discussion on the role of faith in dealing with global issues.
This is also the topic of a class Blair is teaching at Yale University this fall. The University videotaped the first lecture, and it can be seen on the school's web site.
This is also the topic of a class Blair is teaching at Yale University this fall. The University videotaped the first lecture, and it can be seen on the school's web site.
Labels:
Education,
Illness,
Islam,
Politics,
Public Relations
Saturday, September 20, 2008
Story about raising awareness raises awareness
We had an after-hours speaker on campus this week, and I was surprised to see one of my graduate students carry a canteen into the library auditorium and, after a while, down the whole thing. Then I remembered that she is Muslim and this is Ramadan.
This is the topic of this artice in the Dallas Morning News. The article is one of a pair dealing with struggles faced by Muslim schoolchildren who fast.
One of the articles dealt with raising awareness for the other students. I thought it was neat how the article also served to raise awareness, for a much bigger population.
This is the topic of this artice in the Dallas Morning News. The article is one of a pair dealing with struggles faced by Muslim schoolchildren who fast.
One of the articles dealt with raising awareness for the other students. I thought it was neat how the article also served to raise awareness, for a much bigger population.
Wednesday, September 3, 2008
Sites give background on Ramadan
The start of this week marked the beginning of the period of Ramadan for Muslims around the world. Some varied sites for basic background for students include:
From holidays.net on scheduling
From USA Today on acts of charity
A site targeted at children
and
An interesting page from the White House.
From holidays.net on scheduling
From USA Today on acts of charity
A site targeted at children
and
An interesting page from the White House.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)